95 replies to this topic

[straykat]

stevea11, on 27 September 2012 - 05:49 AM, said:

Is it just me or am I crazy. If I close my eyes and listen to him talk I swear he sounds just like Hawkeye Pierce. (Alan Alda)

I'm voting crazy. But that doesn't mean you are wrong about the voice.

[NYROSE]

Found the idol...told someone about it...hope it works for an alliance for him. He has a down to earth quality that I like want to see him stay.

[6Borders]

I'm liking him a little better than last time.  
Strange that he immediately told a new tribe member that he has the idol!  
I guess there is a strategy in there somewhere.

[KyTallgirl]

I thought it was very strange (and stupid) that Pete told Malcolm right off the bat too that he had an immunity idol, although I'm glad he did.  I like Malcolm.

[NYROSE]

Waaaaaay too trusting. Malcolm did not share his info.

[NYROSE]

Penner irritated me when he was griping that Denise was on his tribe instead of Malcolm. She won her challenge. He could not have asked for better. and should not have.

[6Borders]

NYROSE, on 18 October 2012 - 04:10 PM, said:

Waaaaaay too trusting. Malcolm did not share his info.

Yeah, it seems like the vet blew it and the newbie made a smart game play!!!!

[sisu power]

stevea11, on 27 September 2012 - 05:49 AM, said:

Is it just me or am I crazy. If I close my eyes and listen to him talk I swear he sounds just like Hawkeye Pierce. (Alan Alda)

     YES!  I hear it, too.   Of course, there is the possibility that we're both crazy!

[jersey721]

I thought Penner was a goner for sure.  I'm so happy he survived.

[KyTallgirl]

jersey721, on 25 October 2012 - 05:29 AM, said:

I thought Penner was a goner for sure.  I'm so happy he survived.

I thought he was gone too!  I'm glad they kept him.  It would've been stupid to get rid of him just yet anyways IMO.  Katie sure wasn't any help at all in those challenges.

[6Borders]

He should have been gone but once again TV (Probst & CBS) stepped up to Tribal and outed the plan to get rid of him.  He's prob Survivor's "Boston Rob" of this season and they will do everything they can to keep him!

[jersey721]

6Borders, on 25 October 2012 - 09:48 AM, said:

He should have been gone but once again TV (Probst & CBS) stepped up to Tribal and outed the plan to get rid of him.  He's prob Survivor's "Boston Rob" of this season and they will do everything they can to keep him!

What???  You must be watching a different show than me.  Probst did no such thing.

[NYROSE]

Yeah probst went after Katie so maybe that was how Penner's oust was skuttled

[6Borders]

Maybe I'm the one paying attention.  Over and over Probst talked about blindslides, just pretty much led Penner down the path of "what happens if".  Probst was totally trying to get Penner to see that he might get voted out, the rest pretty much caught on and figured he would probably use the idol so voted out Katie.  Of course, this is all just my opinion and now I saw it and there is A LOT of editing on Survivor so we really don't know.

[pinkie]

I don't think that Probst possibly (and I don't think he did) putting any ideas in Penners head, and clearly he didn't since Penner didn't use the idol, would have changed their vote, why would they? They couldn't decide between Penner and Katie anyway, so the worst that happened if Penner used it was Katie went anyway and they got the idol out of play.....

[KyTallgirl]

I'm glad he played his idol and foiled Jeff Kent's plan.  It was a good show last night...kept you guessing on who was getting the boot.

[NYROSE]

onlly bad thing was that his use of the idol meant that rc went if only one had switched to getting pete off I did like rc's attitude

[Slimcruz]

I don't like Penner.  Dunno why exactly but don't.  Probst went on and on and on and on about blindside so hello.

[stevea11]

Slimcruz, on 01 November 2012 - 06:22 AM, said:

I don't like Penner.  Dunno why exactly but don't.  Probst went on and on and on and on about blindside so hello.

Agreed. Probst seems to be calling people out allot for there screw ups these days. Pour a little gas on the fire will ya there Jeffy boy.

[KyTallgirl]

I think he is too....WAY more than in past seasons.  I don't necessarily think he is biased towards or against any certain person, but he definitely is prodding them a lot at tribal counsel.