36 replies to this topic

[Slimcruz]

Again, she is such a beautiful girl. Fabulous voice. All wrong for AI but she is going places, I do believe.

[itsnotbb9]

So boring! She sings well but this is more than just a singing competition, you need to have personality too.

[gizzmotor]

She had a great voice, but no stage presence at all...I really think she should have waited a year or two, before coming out on Idol, she is just really young and needs more experience.

[Califcyclone]

Thia is a great example of why 15/16/17 is just too young.
She may have the natural ability just not the depth and breadth need for AI.
I felt the same about Jordan Sparks - good but not the package.

[itsnotbb9]

Thia is a great example of why 15/16/17 is just too young.
She may have the natural ability just not the depth and breadth need for AI.
I felt the same about Jordan Sparks - good but not the package.

I agree. Lauren and Thia have great voices but I just don't see them as stars. And even teenagers from seasons past (David Archuleta, Katie Stevens, Dianna Degarmo, etc.) who were good never really made it big.

Do you think this about Scotty, too? For me, he is the exception to this rule - I think he's got it.

[Califcyclone]

I put Scotty right in there (at least for me).
I cringe when I hear him sing about turning the light low...
Nice song to showcase his talent but he is just 17.

I put Scotty in same pool as Thia.

[gizzmotor]

No way Scotty is much stronger then Thia...She has no stage presence.

Thia has all of Guam voting for her.....LMAO

[uvp]

[itsnotbb9]

I'm happy she was in the bottom this week. She definitely deserved it and I hope she either steps it up or goes home soon.

[uvp]

sung it beautiful but maybe too beautiful

[Slimcruz]

Such a pretty girl. Such a pretty voice.

[gizzmotor]

I got it! Simon you are singing old songs for such a young girl...Ballad what a surprise.

[itsnotbb9]

She was ok, but I bet her fans voted extra for her last night so I she's probably still safe.

[uvp]

[itsnotbb9]

Thank goodness I was wrong! I am very happy to see her go.

[Slimcruz]

She was so out of place on that show. Never had a chance.

[Slowpoke]

Sooo young

It's best she has a chance to grow up and get more experience.

Who knows... we could see her sometime - somewhere further down the line.

Pretty little voice for her age tho... gotta give her that