72 replies to this topic

[SugarB]

I really like that song, and I loved him doing it.

[Slimcruz]

Ditto, SugarB. Casey and James took it all tonight, imo. Great performance.

[uvp]

old casey has returned totally hated the performance

vocals were bad

[SugarB]

old casey has returned totally hated the performance

vocals were bad

Sadly, I agree. I have been a Casey supporter, but he might have signed his death (as in exit) warrent with that mess tonight.

[Slimcruz]

I think that Casey is very talented in his musical genre. I like and admire a little bit of that kind of jazzy style but not my go to sounds. I do think that AI will prompt him for a bigger audience; as it should.

[uvp]

entertaining but not so sure the vocals were up to par

[SugarB]

I really liked what Casey did last night. It was fun to watch. I do worry about his safety though, because I know not everyone "gets" him.

[uvp]

i hate when he sings this way

not my cup of tea

[Oleander]

i hate when he sings this way

not my cup of tea

I think you're probably in the majority but I loved it. I'm not a big fan of pop music so maybe that (plus my age) is why I like what Casey does.

[uvp]

so long growling

[gizzmotor]

I like Casey, sorry to see him leave...Thought for sure it would be Jacob

[SugarB]

I liked the guy, but he is not winning material IMO, so he had to go sooner or later. Jacob next week please!!!!

[Slimcruz]

I think that Casey is a big musical talent with charisma but was ill-suited for American Idol except for the industry exposure it gave him. I liked him more and more as time went on but he is not mainstream.