75 replies to this topic

[Dade]

Haley Reinhart

20 years old | Wheeling, IL

[uvp]

i am still amazed that she made it on public vote to top 5 voter getter for ladies

i dont see her lasting past top 10

sub-par vocalist imo

[Slimcruz]

I don't remember her.

[King123]

WORST of the top 13.. I hope she leaves this week. Crazy suprised she made top 5 girls.

[uvp]

boring not good but i hate that funny growl she makes

it ruins the whole performance for me

[Fatcat]

I didnt like the vocal yoddle as Jen put it, too predictable and trying to sound too Patsy, Patsy did record that song, and Leann sorta put the Patsy spin on it first, so nope I am not a fan of this Chicky

[gizzmotor]

I do not think she did anything for herself last night....I could hear Simon saying to her " To old of a song, for such a young girl. Just hated it" I really like Hailey, but better start picking song choices better.

[Slimcruz]

I think that she was fabulous. That performance bought her a career.

[SugarB]

She sang it well, but not sure that the song choice did her any favors at all. She definitely has that "siren" sort of thing going on though.

[bboop]

I still like her voice, but the song did nothing for me.

[Poptart]

I think she did great.

[itsnotbb9]

I wasn't crazy about the yodeling, but I don't think she was the worst - I'd like to see her stay this week.

[CeCiMom]

Better than some but, not all.

[uvp]

not good pitchy hard to understand what she sung

yodeling got to go

wrong song choice voice not meant for that song

[Slimcruz]

I still like her. I didn't like the song. She should do some Sheryl Crow.

[CeCiMom]

I'm still rooting for her... she didn't execute tonight's song very well but, there's is something feisty about her that I enjoy and I like her vocals and I think if/when she ever gets comfortable on stage she will be a fun performer to watch.

[gizzmotor]

I really like Hailey, but not sure she did herself any good last night....She needs to be better at her song choices...I think she will find herself in the bottom tonight. I just hope she will stay.

[SugarB]

I don't think she has the best voice of the bunch but she has a very interesting voice. This week was much better than last week. I think she relies a little too much on her sex appeal. Work on the music first, then the sexy will just be there!

[Fatcat]

I think her biggest problem is her, she comes off to me as kinda thinkin shes all that, and then doesnt really deliver, she has the voice but is not doing the right stuff or with enough oomph

[itsnotbb9]

I thought she was good last night. She looked amazing and I really like her voice, I hope she stays again this week.