Forgot your password?
Or sign in with one of these services
Athena28, May 11, 2008 in Survivor 16: Archive
48 members have voted
My vote is #3.
My vote is for Marcellas.. As I recall, he did what he did on his own accord. Erik was tricked. Even the best can be led astray, but it takes a real idiot to do it yourself.
I voted for Eric.
Erik by far!
After being present for all the other fools who were duped before you and you STILL gave up immunity. He could have won every challenge after that and basically won the game and those girls knew that!
I kept screaming.. "dont do it! stupid!"
They both are, in their own ways.
I voted #3! They were both Dumb.......who do I feel the sorriest for? Eric!
Erik was so likeable. My heart hurt when he gave it away.
Erik made the dumber move BY FAR. Marcellas wasn't going to win BB, but Erik had a very very good chance at the big money. In the final 4, winning all the comps. Biggest blunder in reality television history.
There's no need for Jeff to even ask "if the holder of the immunity necklace would like to give it to someone else", because it ain't never gonna happen again.
Well if someone has the HII, he may give up the II. But, yeah you are right. I don't see anyone except a total moron giving it up again.
I would of been VERY Happy losing the final 2, getting big money.. then getting 5th place.
My vote is for Eric! Sweet guy though!
Its hard to compare BB and Survivor to each other, such different shows.. apples and oranges.
I actually like the reactions of the hosts best....
Eric: Jeff (like a tender big brother) said that he suspects he learned a life lesson
Marcellas: Julie hit Marci upside the head with one of her index cards and said what were you thinking.
That was win I started like the chin.